How the EU is Defining Green Hydrogen: Key Rules and Challenges

Green hydrogen is poised to play a pivotal role in the European Union’s (EU) ambitious plans to decarbonise its economy. As the world grapples with climate change, the EU has taken significant steps to ensure that hydrogen production is genuinely sustainable.  

In July 2023, the EU introduced new rules to define what makes hydrogen “green.” These rules, built on three key pillars, aim to ensure that green hydrogen production is both environmentally and economically viable. This blog post delves into these rules and the challenges they present.

The Importance of Green Hydrogen

Green hydrogen, produced using renewable energy sources, is seen as a cornerstone of the EU’s strategy to reduce carbon emissions. Unlike grey hydrogen, which is produced from natural gas and emits significant CO2, green hydrogen offers a clean alternative.  

Currently, the green hydrogen industry is in its early stages, but its potential impact is immense. By 2030, the EU aims to produce and import 20 million tonnes of renewable hydrogen, highlighting its critical role in the energy transition. The EU’s broader goal is for renewable hydrogen to cover around 10% of its energy needs by 2050.

The EU’s New Rules for Green Hydrogen

Background

The EU’s decision to establish clear rules for green hydrogen stems from the need to ensure that the production process is truly sustainable. Without stringent guidelines, there is a risk that fossil fuels could inadvertently support hydrogen production, undermining its green credentials.

The Three Pillars

1. Additionality:

This principle mandates that the renewable electricity used for hydrogen production must come from new or recently built facilities. This ensures that the demand for green hydrogen drives the creation of new renewable energy sources rather than diverting existing ones.

2. Time Matching

Renewable electricity must be matched to hydrogen production on an hourly basis. This means that the electricity used to produce hydrogen must be generated at the same time the hydrogen is being produced, ensuring a direct link between renewable energy generation and hydrogen production. 

3. Geographical Matching

The renewable electricity must be generated in the same location as the hydrogen production facility. This reduces the need for long-distance electricity transmission, which can lead to energy losses and inefficiencies. 

4. Implementation Timeline
The EU has outlined a transition phase for these rules, allowing stakeholders time to adapt. Key dates and milestones have been set to ensure a smooth implementation process.

Challenges & Controversies

Industry Concerns

The new rules have sparked significant debate within the industry. Many stakeholders argue that the requirements for additionality and immediate hourly matching impose undue burdens on the green hydrogen sector. They fear that these stringent rules could stifle innovation and slow down the development of green hydrogen projects.

Environmental Perspectives

Environmental groups, on the other hand, advocate for strict implementation of the three pillars. They argue that lenient rules could paradoxically increase grid-wide emissions, as fossil fuels might fill the gap if renewable energy is insufficient.

 
Economic Implications

The economic impact of these rules is another area of concern. While the rules aim to ensure sustainability, they also increase the cost and complexity of green hydrogen production. Balancing these economic implications with environmental goals is a key challenge for policymakers.

Global Implications

Influence on Other Jurisdictions

The EU’s approach to green hydrogen is likely to influence policies in other regions, particularly the United States. As the US Treasury prepares to issue guidelines under the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), the debate over what constitutes green hydrogen is heating up.

Comparative Analysis

Comparing the EU’s approach with emerging guidelines in the US reveals different strategies to achieve similar goals. While the EU focuses on stringent rules to ensure sustainability, the US is exploring ways to balance industry growth with environmental integrity.

The Path Forward

Balancing Act

The green hydrogen sector faces a delicate balancing act. Policymakers must ensure that public funding is used effectively to kickstart the industry while maintaining rigorous standards to ensure that hydrogen production is genuinely green.

Policy Recommendations

To address these challenges, policymakers could consider phased implementation of the rules, providing flexibility for early-stage projects while gradually tightening standards. Collaboration between industry and regulators is crucial to finding workable solutions.

Future Outlook

Looking ahead, the future of green hydrogen in the EU and globally appears promising. With the right policies and industry cooperation, green hydrogen can become a cornerstone of the global energy transition, helping to achieve climate goals and drive economic growth.

The EU’s new rules for green hydrogen represent a significant step towards a sustainable energy future. While the challenges are substantial, the potential benefits are immense. By balancing industry needs with environmental goals, the EU can lead the way in defining what truly makes hydrogen “green.”  

As the industry evolves, so too will the need for skilled professionals to drive these changes.  Contact our renewable energy industry recruitment experts today to discuss how we can help you build a team that will lead the way in sustainable energy solutions. Whether you need engineers, project managers, or sustainability consultants, we have the expertise to find the right talent for your needs.